Contrapunctus
Guided journeys24 minutes · 9 stations

Rachmaninoff in exile

Russian scores and American recordings

Rachmaninoff left Russia with his family in December 1917; by the following November he was in New York, earning his living at the piano. His records took the music of Moscow and Ivanovka into American studios, from the three notes of the C♯ minor Prelude to the short phrases of Lilacs.

Begin plays the stations in order; Pause stops playback at the current station.
Station 01 09

The C♯ minor Prelude, 1892

Sergei Rachmaninoff · Prelude in C♯ minor, Op. 3 No. 2

The Prelude opens with three heavy notes, A–G♯–C♯, answered quietly in chords. Rachmaninoff wrote it in 1892, the year he finished his composition studies at the Moscow Conservatory, after years of training with Zverev, Siloti, Taneyev and Arensky. The following March he presented Tchaikovsky with the five piano pieces of Op. 3; the older composer especially liked the Prelude. Rachmaninoff recorded the piece for Edison in 1919. In the quiet answers the upper notes are joined into a melody above the changing chords.

Sources & recording

Sergei Rachmaninoff
Excerpt 0:00–⁠1:46 · Full recording & listening notes

  1. A–G♯–C♯ is played loudly; the answering chords are quiet.
  2. The upper notes of the chords carry a continuous melody.
Places on record · 1892123
  1. Moscow · studied · documented
    1889–⁠1892

    Lived with the Satins; studied with Siloti, Taneyev and Arensky.

  2. Ivanovka · lived · documented
    1890–⁠1917

    Returned to the Satin family estate to compose, later owning and managing it.

  3. Moscow · premiere · documented
    1892-09

    Introduced his C-sharp minor Prelude at the Moscow Electrical Exhibition.

Dated places on a present-day coastline.

This year on the Map
Station 02 09

The Prelude’s early circulation

Sergei Rachmaninoff · Prelude in C♯ minor, Op. 3 No. 2

Siloti took the Prelude on his 1898 tour of Europe, England and America, and its fame travelled ahead of Rachmaninoff, who was still living in Russia. The slow opening chords are followed by an Agitato in triplets, after which the three-note motif returns across the keyboard. At that point the score is written on four staves instead of two for the pianist’s two hands. A quiet coda follows, in which the chords move apart, and the piece ends softly.

Sources & recording

Sergei Rachmaninoff
Excerpt 1:46–⁠3:47 · Full recording & listening notes

  1. Triplets carry the melody through the Agitato.
  2. The three-note call returns in broad chords; the printed score now stretches over four staves.
  3. In the coda the chords are spread apart and the piano part fades to silence.
Places on record · 1892123
  1. Moscow · studied · documented
    1889–⁠1892

    Lived with the Satins; studied with Siloti, Taneyev and Arensky.

  2. Ivanovka · lived · documented
    1890–⁠1917

    Returned to the Satin family estate to compose, later owning and managing it.

  3. Moscow · premiere · documented
    1892-09

    Introduced his C-sharp minor Prelude at the Moscow Electrical Exhibition.

Dated places on a present-day coastline.

This year on the Map
Station 03 09

Lilacs at Ivanovka

Sergei Rachmaninoff · Lilacs, Op. 21 No. 5 (composer’s piano transcription)

Rachmaninoff wrote Lilacs in 1902 at Ivanovka, the Satin family’s estate near Tambov. In Ekaterina Beketova’s poem the speaker goes among the flowers in search of happiness. He later arranged the song as a piano piece, setting its melody among broken chords and triplets and adding short cadenzas. On 27 December 1923 he recorded that version for Victor in Camden, New Jersey. The piano part becomes quicker and fuller, pauses on a trill, then returns to the quiet melody. The final flourish adds a few more notes around the tune.

Sources & recording

Sergei Rachmaninoff, piano
Excerpt 0:00–⁠2:33 · Full recording & listening notes

  1. The melody is played inside the piano’s broken chords and triplets.
  2. The piano plays faster and louder, up to a trill held under a pause.
  3. A short flourish leads to a soft closing chord.
Rachmaninoff stands second from the left at Ivanovka, mid-1890s. Photograph by an unknown photographer.
Rachmaninoff stands second from the left at Ivanovka, mid-1890s. Photograph by an unknown photographer. Image source ↗
Places on record · 1902
Places on record · 190212
  1. Ivanovka · lived · documented
    1890–⁠1917

    Returned to the Satin family estate to compose, later owning and managing it.

  2. Moscow · lived · documented
    1900–⁠1904

    Underwent treatment with Nikolai Dahl and returned to composing.

Dated places on a present-day coastline.

This year on the Map
Station 04 09

Twenty-four keys

Sergei Rachmaninoff · Prelude in B minor, Op. 32 No. 10
Lento

By 1910 twenty-three more preludes had followed the C♯ minor Prelude. The ten preludes of Op. 23 and the thirteen of Op. 32 completed Rachmaninoff’s set in all the major and minor keys. This is the B minor, played here by La Pianista in 2010. Marked Lento, it begins with small moving figures against held chords. The two hands move together in a rocking figure, then pause. The phrases gradually take on heavier chords, and the marking becomes pesante.

Sources & recording

La Pianista
Excerpt 0:00–⁠2:48 · Full recording & listening notes

  1. Small figures rock against held chords in B minor.
  2. The chords become heavier as the pesante passage approaches.
  3. The broad chords begin to subside; quieter notes follow.
Places on record · 1910123
  1. Ivanovka · lived · documented
    1890–⁠1917

    Returned to the Satin family estate to compose, later owning and managing it.

  2. Moscow · lived · documented
    1909–⁠1917

    Returned to Russia; led the Moscow Philharmonic Society from 1911 to 1913.

  3. Carnegie Hall New York · worked · documented
    1910-01

    Performed his Third Concerto with Mahler conducting.

Dated places on a present-day coastline.

This year on the Map
Station 05 09

December 1917: departure from Russia

Sergei Rachmaninoff · Prelude in B minor, Op. 32 No. 10
Lento

In December 1917 Rachmaninoff left Russia with his wife and two daughters. They travelled through Finland to Sweden, then settled in Copenhagen before sailing for New York in November 1918. He never saw Russia again. The B minor Prelude was already seven years old when they left. After its climax it continues with long notes surrounded by quick decoration. The opening phrases return quietly after the middle section. Near the end the bass descends and the spaces between the piano’s last sounds grow wider.

Sources & recording

La Pianista
Excerpt 2:48–⁠5:21 · Full recording & listening notes

  1. Quick ornamental figures surround the longer held notes.
  2. The small rocking phrases of the opening return.
  3. The low notes and the last quiet chord die away.
Places on record · 191712345
  1. Ivanovka · lived · documented
    1890–⁠1917

    Returned to the Satin family estate to compose, later owning and managing it.

  2. Moscow · lived · documented
    1909–⁠1917

    Returned to Russia; led the Moscow Philharmonic Society from 1911 to 1913.

  3. Yalta · travelled · documented
    1917-09-05

    Gave his last concert in Russia before emigration.

  4. Helsinki · exile · documented
    1917-12

    Crossed from revolutionary Russia with his wife and daughters.

  5. Stockholm · exile · documented
    1917-12–⁠1918-01

    Arrived after leaving Russia and prepared Scandinavian engagements.

Dated places on a present-day coastline.

This year on the Map
Station 06 09

America: Edison and Victor recordings

Sergei Rachmaninoff · Prelude in C♯ minor, Op. 3 No. 2

In America, Rachmaninoff worked full-time as a concert pianist. Recording became another part of that work. He recorded for Edison in 1919, signed a contract with Victor in 1920, and returned to the studio repeatedly with pieces he knew intimately. On 4 April 1928, in New York, he recorded the C♯ minor Prelude again, this time electrically. Victor issued take 23. The opening chords state the same three-note figure heard earlier, and the triplets accelerate towards the return of the opening material. The coda is quiet.

Sources & recording

Sergei Rachmaninoff, piano
Excerpt 0:00–⁠3:30 · Full recording & listening notes

  1. Rachmaninoff recorded his Prelude again in New York on 4 April 1928, take 23.
  2. The triplets of the middle section begin.
  3. The opening call is played in broad chords across the keyboard.
  4. The chords become quieter and are spaced apart as the coda begins.
Konstantin Somov, Sergei Rachmaninoff, 1925: the composer during his American recording years.
Konstantin Somov, Sergei Rachmaninoff, 1925: the composer during his American recording years. Image source ↗
Places on record · 1918
Places on record · 191812345
  1. Stockholm · exile · documented
    1917-12–⁠1918-01

    Arrived after leaving Russia and prepared Scandinavian engagements.

  2. Copenhagen · exile · documented
    1918-01–⁠1918-10

    Gave concerts while deciding where to settle.

  3. Oslo · travelled · documented
    1918-11-01

    Departed Kristiania by ship for America.

  4. New York City · exile · documented
    1918-11-12–⁠1942

    Established his American base; bought 33 Riverside Drive in 1921.

  5. Providence Rhode Island · travelled · documented
    1918-12-08

    Began the concert season that established his American performing career.

Dated places on a present-day coastline.

This year on the Map
Other performancesRachmaninoff, Prelude Op. 3 No. 2, in four recordingsPerformances compared
Station 07 09

Philadelphia: the Concerto recording on shellac

Sergei Rachmaninoff · Piano Concerto No. 2, Op. 18
I. Moderato — opening 78-rpm side only

During Rachmaninoff’s treatment in Moscow in 1900, Nikolai Dahl repeated to him the promise “You will begin to write your concerto”. The Second Concerto, completed the following year, was dedicated to Dahl. In this recording, made at the Academy of Music on 10 April 1929, Rachmaninoff plays it with Stokowski and the Philadelphia Orchestra. The piano opens with bell-like chords that grow louder; the strings then take the melody while the piano plays running notes beneath them. The excerpt fills the first side of the original disc. The melody is still continuing when the side ends, at the point where a gramophone owner would have had to change the record.

Sources & recording

Sergei Rachmaninoff, piano; Philadelphia Orchestra; Leopold Stokowski, conductor
Excerpt 0:00–⁠3:09 · Full recording & listening notes

  1. The piano begins alone with repeated chords.
  2. The strings have the melody; the piano plays beneath them.
  3. The piano plays a quieter phrase.
  4. The first disc side is nearly over; the movement continues on the next record.
Station 08 09

Summer home on Lake Lucerne

Sergei Rachmaninoff · Piano Concerto No. 2, Op. 18
II. Adagio sostenuto — opening 78-rpm side only

In the Second Concerto’s Adagio, muted strings introduce a melody for flute and clarinet above the piano’s moving notes. Rachmaninoff and Stokowski recorded this opening side in Philadelphia in 1929. Five years later, beside Lake Lucerne, Rachmaninoff was writing the Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini for piano and orchestra. Villa Senar was his summer home from 1933 to 1939. There he wrote twenty-four variations on Paganini’s last Caprice and brought in another old tune, the Dies irae. In Variation VII the piano plays that chant against fragments of Paganini’s melody.

Sources & recording

Sergei Rachmaninoff, piano; Philadelphia Orchestra; Leopold Stokowski, conductor
Excerpt 0:00–⁠3:04 · Full recording & listening notes

  1. Muted strings open the Second Concerto’s Adagio.
  2. Flute, then clarinet, play over the piano’s circling notes.
  3. Piano and orchestra continue the Adagio’s long melody.
  4. The first Adagio side ends; the movement continues on another disc.
Places on record · 1934123
  1. New York City · exile · documented
    1918-11-12–⁠1942

    Established his American base; bought 33 Riverside Drive in 1921.

  2. Villa Senar · lived · documented
    1933–⁠1939

    Composed and rested at his Hertenstein home on Lake Lucerne.

  3. Lyric Baltimore · premiere · documented
    1934-11-07

    Played the Paganini Rhapsody with Stokowski and the Philadelphia Orchestra.

Dated places on a present-day coastline.

This year on the Map
Influence
Station 09 09

Lilacs, revisited

Sergei Rachmaninoff · Lilacs, Op. 21 No. 5 (composer’s piano transcription)

Rachmaninoff died at home in Beverly Hills in March 1943. Twenty years earlier, in Camden, he had recorded Lilacs. Victor’s books list twelve takes between 1920 and 1923; this is the ninth, recorded on 27 December 1923. The song’s melody passes through the moving notes, gathers into a trill and returns to a quiet close. A last short flourish leads to the closing chord.

Sources & recording

Sergei Rachmaninoff, piano
Excerpt 0:00–⁠2:33 · Full recording & listening notes

  1. The 1923 Lilacs returns, its melody set among the moving notes.
  2. After the trill and the quicker passage, the piano plays quietly again.
  3. The final run ends on a quiet chord.
Ivanovka, mid-1890s: Rachmaninoff stands among the people of the estate where he later wrote Lilacs.
Ivanovka, mid-1890s: Rachmaninoff stands among the people of the estate where he later wrote Lilacs. Image source ↗
Places on record · 1943
Places on record · 194312345
  1. Beverly Hills California · lived · documented
    1942–⁠1943

    Bought 610 North Elm Drive, his final home.

  2. Kensico Cemetery · buried · documented
    1943

    Buried in Valhalla, New York.

  3. Chicago · travelled · documented
    1943-02

    Gave his final concerto performances.

  4. Knoxville Tennessee · travelled · documented
    1943-02-17

    Gave his final recital at the University of Tennessee.

  5. Beverly Hills California · died · documented
    1943-03-28

    Died at his Elm Drive home.

Dated places on a present-day coastline.

This year on the Map
Station 1 of 90:00 / 1:46

Press Begin to start playback.

← → stations · Space pauses · swipe to change station