Contrapunctus
Johannes Vermeer, The Music Lesson
Jacques-Louis David, The Oath of the Horatii
Caspar David Friedrich, Two Men Contemplating the Moon
Gustav Klimt, Beethoven Frieze: The Well-Armed Strong One
James McNeill Whistler, Nocturne: Blue and Gold — Old Battersea Bridge
Wassily Kandinsky, Impression III (Concert)
Paul Klee, Ad Parnassum

Contrapunctus

An illustrated atlas of composers · Bach to the presentWestern art music from Bach to the present, with historical recordings and the scores. The chapters cover how the harmony works, where the forms came from, what each composer took from the others, and the paintings and poems connected with the music.

Introduction
Prelude

Introduction

The Concert Hall plays historical and openly licensed recordings, from plainchant to Boulez’s Le Marteau sans maître, in the order the composers were born. Short notes appear as the music reaches them, and where a score is available, the page moves with the sound. Each of the evenings below can also be played straight through without choosing individual pieces.

Each composer has a chapter. It gives the life, in the composer’s own words where they survive; what the music is made of; the works to start with; short examples to play; and the paintings and poems associated with the music. Every piece in the Hall has a page of its own, with all its recordings and all its notes.

The chapters overlap, as the periods of music do. In 1909 Rachmaninoff wrote his Third Piano Concerto for his first American tour, and Schoenberg wrote his Three Piano Pieces, Op. 11, which have no home key. The Web of Influence and the Map follow the connections between composers, such as a copied score, a borrowed tune or two composers in the same city in the same year.

Where a story is legend, the text says whose legend it is. The sources are given on every page.

The Concert Hall

Evenings

Each plays straight through in the Concert Hall, with the notes and, where available, the score, and stops at the end.

11 pieces · 1 h 11 min

A first evening

Bach to Ravel in seventy minutes

Bach’s aria, a Vivaldi spring and Handel’s chorus come first, followed by the opening movements of two symphonies, a Viennese winter song, a Chopin nocturne and Paris at the turn of the twentieth century. The last piece is built on a single drum rhythm, played 169 times.

10 pieces · 1 h 17 min

Paris, 1888–⁠1913

From Satie’s Gymnopédies to The Rite of Spring

The evening covers twenty-five years in Paris. It includes the first Gymnopédie, which Satie wrote in Montmartre, Debussy accompanying Mary Garden, the flute that opens the Faune, Ravel’s harp, the drowned cathedral, and two Stravinsky ballets that the Ballets Russes brought to Paris.

8 pieces · 1 h 9 min

Vienna, from Haydn to Schoenberg

A hundred and twenty years of music in one city

Haydn’s surprise, Mozart’s G minor, the symphony Schubert never finished, the hurdy-gurdy man at the end of Winterreise, Brahms in C minor, Mahler’s Adagietto, and Schoenberg’s night walk and his step into “the air of another planet”.

9 pieces · 54 min

Composers as performers

Grieg, Debussy, Rachmaninoff, Elgar, Ravel and Stravinsky performing their own music

Every recording here has the composer at the piano or on the podium, from Grieg in Paris in 1903 to Stravinsky in 1960. Each plays at his own tempos and departs from his own written markings where he chooses.

9 pieces · 1 h 2 min

Late at night

Slow music for late evening

Bach’s alto aria after Peter’s denial, the slow movement of Mozart’s last concerto, the adagio of Schubert’s Quintet, a Chopin nocturne, Schumann’s Träumerei, Debussy’s Clair de lune, the last page of Fauré’s Requiem and Mahler’s Adagietto.

11 pieces · 41 min

The first recordings

Grieg to Elgar, 1903–⁠1928

Musicians playing and singing into a recording horn, and from 1925 into a microphone. Grieg, Caruso, Nikisch’s Berlin Philharmonic, Paderewski, Chaliapin, de Pachmann, and Elgar conducting his own march.

10 pieces · 40 min

Opera

Rossini to Puccini

The evening includes Figaro’s entrance in Seville; the chorus of the Hebrew slaves, which Toscanini conducted when Verdi was buried in 1901; the Habanera and the Toreador Song from Carmen; the clown’s aria associated with Caruso; and Tosca’s prayer. The orchestra plays Rossini’s overture and Wagner’s Valkyries on its own.

5 pieces · 43 min

Music in America

Dvořák in New York to Copland’s Lincoln

Dvořák wrote his Largo in New York in 1893 and told American composers to turn to their own folk songs. The evening continues with three American composers: Ives’s music on the Alcotts’ house in Concord; Gershwin’s Rhapsody in the 1924 recording by Gershwin and Paul Whiteman’s band; and Copland’s fanfare and his portrait of Lincoln, with Carl Sandburg reading Lincoln’s words.

Chapters

Bach to the present in seven chapters

Each chapter opens with a painting from its own years and an account of the changes in harmony, in form and in the instruments themselves.

Jacques-Louis David, The Oath of the Horatii, 1784
Jacques-⁠Louis DavidThe Oath of the Horatii, 1784Oil on canvas · Musée du Louvre, Paris
II1750–⁠1827

Classical

A melody’s first phrase stops on an unsettled chord, and its answer comes to rest in the home key. Haydn could place a joke at the expected ending, and Mozart gave the piano a singing part among the orchestral winds. In Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony, three trombones enter for the first time in the last movement.

Read the chapter
Caspar David Friedrich, Two Men Contemplating the Moon, 1819–20
Caspar David FriedrichTwo Men Contemplating the Moon, 1819–⁠20Oil on canvas · Galerie Neue Meister, Dresden
III1815–⁠1890

Romanticism

In Schubert’s Erlkönig, one singer takes the parts of a father and his terrified child while the piano plays the horse’s gallop throughout. In Berlioz’s orchestral writing a melody carries a story and returns in a grotesque version. In her piano cycle, Fanny Hensel wrote a piece for each month of the year.

Read the chapter
Gustav Klimt, Beethoven Frieze: The Well-Armed Strong One, 1901–02
Gustav KlimtBeethoven Frieze: The Well-⁠Armed Strong One, 1901–⁠02Casein paint, stucco, pencil, glass, mother-of-pearl and gold on mortar · Secession Building, Vienna (Belvedere)
IV1880–⁠1918

Fin de siècle

In Strauss’s orchestra a solo cello plays Don Quixote, who rides at a flock of sheep he mistakes for an army. Mahler writes for eight horns and a children’s chorus, and for a brass solo played offstage.

Read the chapter
Wassily Kandinsky, Impression III (Concert), 1911
Wassily KandinskyImpression III (Concert), 1911Oil on canvas · Städtische Galerie im Lenbachhaus, Munich
VI1908–⁠1945

Modernism

Schoenberg took a soprano beyond the home key; Stravinsky had one repeated chord accented at unexpected moments. Bartók brought village songs home on phonograph cylinders, and Ives set a trumpet’s question over quiet strings. Between the wars, new music acquired its own concert societies and radio orchestras. In 1933 Schoenberg had to leave Germany.

Read the chapter
Paul Klee, Ad Parnassum, 1932
Paul KleeAd Parnassum, 1932Oil and casein on canvas · Kunstmuseum Bern
VII1945–present

After 1945

Two pianists repeat a phrase until one moves ahead of the other. A boy’s recorded voice is multiplied through loudspeakers. After 1945 composers worked in the studio as well as at the piano and on manuscript paper. Britten set an opera in a Suffolk fishing village; Saariaho derived chords from the changing sound of a cello. In 1997 Adès wrote a piece in which a symphony orchestra plays the rhythms of a rave.

Read the chapter
Lifelines

Composers’ lifespans

Every composer in the atlas on one axis. Bach died the year Haydn turned eighteen; Brahms heard the thirty-year-old Mahler conduct Don Giovanni in Budapest in 1890 and praised it; Rachmaninoff outlived Ravel and Mahler and died two years before Bartók.

16501700175018001850190019502000Barbara Strozzi, 1619–⁠1677Barbara Strozzi 1619–⁠1677Élisabeth Jacquet de La Guerre, 1665–⁠1729Élisabeth Jacquet de La Guerre 1665–⁠1729François Couperin, 1668–⁠1733François Couperin 1668–⁠1733Antonio Vivaldi, 1678–⁠1741Antonio Vivaldi 1678–⁠1741Jean-⁠Philippe Rameau, 1683–⁠1764Jean-⁠Philippe Rameau 1683–⁠1764Johann Sebastian Bach, 1685–⁠1750Johann Sebastian Bach 1685–⁠1750George Frideric Handel, 1685–⁠1759George Frideric Handel 1685–⁠1759Domenico Scarlatti, 1685–⁠1757Domenico Scarlatti 1685–⁠1757Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach, 1714–⁠1788Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach 1714–⁠1788Joseph Haydn, 1732–⁠1809Joseph Haydn 1732–⁠1809Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, 1756–⁠1791Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart 1756–⁠1791Ludwig van Beethoven, 1770–⁠1827Ludwig van Beethoven 1770–⁠1827Gioachino Rossini, 1792–⁠1868Gioachino Rossini 1792–⁠1868Franz Schubert, 1797–⁠1828Franz Schubert 1797–⁠1828Hector Berlioz, 1803–⁠1869Hector Berlioz 1803–⁠1869Fanny Hensel, 1805–⁠1847Fanny Hensel 1805–⁠1847Felix Mendelssohn, 1809–⁠1847Felix Mendelssohn 1809–⁠1847Frédéric Chopin, 1810–⁠1849Frédéric Chopin 1810–⁠1849Robert Schumann, 1810–⁠1856Robert Schumann 1810–⁠1856Franz Liszt, 1811–⁠1886Franz Liszt 1811–⁠1886Giuseppe Verdi, 1813–⁠1901Giuseppe Verdi 1813–⁠1901Richard Wagner, 1813–⁠1883Richard Wagner 1813–⁠1883Clara Schumann, 1819–⁠1896Clara Schumann 1819–⁠1896Anton Bruckner, 1824–⁠1896Anton Bruckner 1824–⁠1896Bedřich Smetana, 1824–⁠1884Bedřich Smetana 1824–⁠1884Alexander Borodin, 1833–⁠1887Alexander Borodin 1833–⁠1887Johannes Brahms, 1833–⁠1897Johannes Brahms 1833–⁠1897Camille Saint-⁠Saëns, 1835–⁠1921Camille Saint-⁠Saëns 1835–⁠1921Georges Bizet, 1838–⁠1875Georges Bizet 1838–⁠1875Modest Mussorgsky, 1839–⁠1881Modest Mussorgsky 1839–⁠1881Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky, 1840–⁠1893Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky 1840–⁠1893Antonín Dvořák, 1841–⁠1904Antonín Dvořák 1841–⁠1904Edvard Grieg, 1843–⁠1907Edvard Grieg 1843–⁠1907Nikolai Rimsky-⁠Korsakov, 1844–⁠1908Nikolai Rimsky-⁠Korsakov 1844–⁠1908Gabriel Fauré, 1845–⁠1924Gabriel Fauré 1845–⁠1924Leoš Janáček, 1854–⁠1928Leoš Janáček 1854–⁠1928Edward Elgar, 1857–⁠1934Edward Elgar 1857–⁠1934Giacomo Puccini, 1858–⁠1924Giacomo Puccini 1858–⁠1924Gustav Mahler, 1860–⁠1911Gustav Mahler 1860–⁠1911Claude Debussy, 1862–⁠1918Claude Debussy 1862–⁠1918Richard Strauss, 1864–⁠1949Richard Strauss 1864–⁠1949Carl Nielsen, 1865–⁠1931Carl Nielsen 1865–⁠1931Jean Sibelius, 1865–⁠1957Jean Sibelius 1865–⁠1957Erik Satie, 1866–⁠1925Erik Satie 1866–⁠1925Amy Beach, 1867–⁠1944Amy Beach 1867–⁠1944Alexander Scriabin, 1872–⁠1915Alexander Scriabin 1872–⁠1915Ralph Vaughan Williams, 1872–⁠1958Ralph Vaughan Williams 1872–⁠1958Sergei Rachmaninoff, 1873–⁠1943Sergei Rachmaninoff 1873–⁠1943Charles Ives, 1874–⁠1954Charles Ives 1874–⁠1954Arnold Schoenberg, 1874–⁠1951Arnold Schoenberg 1874–⁠1951Maurice Ravel, 1875–⁠1937Maurice Ravel 1875–⁠1937Manuel de Falla, 1876–⁠1946Manuel de Falla 1876–⁠1946Béla Bartók, 1881–⁠1945Béla Bartók 1881–⁠1945Igor Stravinsky, 1882–⁠1971Igor Stravinsky 1882–⁠1971Anton Webern, 1883–⁠1945Anton Webern 1883–⁠1945Alban Berg, 1885–⁠1935Alban Berg 1885–⁠1935Florence Price, 1887–⁠1953Florence Price 1887–⁠1953Heitor Villa-⁠Lobos, 1887–⁠1959Heitor Villa-⁠Lobos 1887–⁠1959Sergei Prokofiev, 1891–⁠1953Sergei Prokofiev 1891–⁠1953Lili Boulanger, 1893–⁠1918Lili Boulanger 1893–⁠1918George Gershwin, 1898–⁠1937George Gershwin 1898–⁠1937Francis Poulenc, 1899–⁠1963Francis Poulenc 1899–⁠1963Aaron Copland, 1900–⁠1990Aaron Copland 1900–⁠1990Dmitri Shostakovich, 1906–⁠1975Dmitri Shostakovich 1906–⁠1975Olivier Messiaen, 1908–⁠1992Olivier Messiaen 1908–⁠1992John Cage, 1912–⁠1992John Cage 1912–⁠1992Benjamin Britten, 1913–⁠1976Benjamin Britten 1913–⁠1976Leonard Bernstein, 1918–⁠1990Leonard Bernstein 1918–⁠1990Iannis Xenakis, 1922–⁠2001Iannis Xenakis 1922–⁠2001György Ligeti, 1923–⁠2006György Ligeti 1923–⁠2006Pierre Boulez, 1925–⁠2016Pierre Boulez 1925–⁠2016Morton Feldman, 1926–⁠1987Morton Feldman 1926–⁠1987György Kurtág, b. 1926György Kurtág b. 1926Sofia Gubaidulina, 1931–⁠2025Sofia Gubaidulina 1931–⁠2025Arvo Pärt, b. 1935Arvo Pärt b. 1935Steve Reich, b. 1936Steve Reich b. 1936Philip Glass, b. 1937Philip Glass b. 1937John Adams, b. 1947John Adams b. 1947Kaija Saariaho, 1952–⁠2023Kaija Saariaho 1952–⁠2023Thomas Adès, b. 1971Thomas Adès b. 1971
  1. Strozzi1619–⁠1677
  2. Jacquet de La Guerre1665–⁠1729
  3. Couperin1668–⁠1733
  4. Vivaldi1678–⁠1741
  5. Rameau1683–⁠1764
  6. J. S. Bach1685–⁠1750
  7. Handel1685–⁠1759
  8. Scarlatti1685–⁠1757
  9. C. P. E. Bach1714–⁠1788
  10. Haydn1732–⁠1809
  11. Mozart1756–⁠1791
  12. Beethoven1770–⁠1827
  13. Rossini1792–⁠1868
  14. Schubert1797–⁠1828
  15. Berlioz1803–⁠1869
  16. Hensel1805–⁠1847
  17. Mendelssohn1809–⁠1847
  18. Chopin1810–⁠1849
  19. Robert Schumann1810–⁠1856
  20. Liszt1811–⁠1886
  21. Verdi1813–⁠1901
  22. Wagner1813–⁠1883
  23. Clara Schumann1819–⁠1896
  24. Bruckner1824–⁠1896
  25. Smetana1824–⁠1884
  26. Borodin1833–⁠1887
  27. Brahms1833–⁠1897
  28. Saint-⁠Saëns1835–⁠1921
  29. Bizet1838–⁠1875
  30. Mussorgsky1839–⁠1881
  31. Tchaikovsky1840–⁠1893
  32. Dvořák1841–⁠1904
  33. Grieg1843–⁠1907
  34. Rimsky-⁠Korsakov1844–⁠1908
  35. Fauré1845–⁠1924
  36. Janáček1854–⁠1928
  37. Elgar1857–⁠1934
  38. Puccini1858–⁠1924
  39. Mahler1860–⁠1911
  40. Debussy1862–⁠1918
  41. Strauss1864–⁠1949
  42. Nielsen1865–⁠1931
  43. Sibelius1865–⁠1957
  44. Satie1866–⁠1925
  45. Beach1867–⁠1944
  46. Scriabin1872–⁠1915
  47. Vaughan Williams1872–⁠1958
  48. Rachmaninoff1873–⁠1943
  49. Ives1874–⁠1954
  50. Schoenberg1874–⁠1951
  51. Ravel1875–⁠1937
  52. Falla1876–⁠1946
  53. Bartók1881–⁠1945
  54. Stravinsky1882–⁠1971
  55. Webern1883–⁠1945
  56. Berg1885–⁠1935
  57. Price1887–⁠1953
  58. Villa-⁠Lobos1887–⁠1959
  59. Prokofiev1891–⁠1953
  60. Boulanger1893–⁠1918
  61. Gershwin1898–⁠1937
  62. Poulenc1899–⁠1963
  63. Copland1900–⁠1990
  64. Shostakovich1906–⁠1975
  65. Messiaen1908–⁠1992
  66. Cage1912–⁠1992
  67. Britten1913–⁠1976
  68. Bernstein1918–⁠1990
  69. Xenakis1922–⁠2001
  70. Ligeti1923–⁠2006
  71. Boulez1925–⁠2016
  72. Feldman1926–⁠1987
  73. Kurtágb. 1926
  74. Gubaidulina1931–⁠2025
  75. Pärtb. 1935
  76. Reichb. 1936
  77. Glassb. 1937
  78. Adamsb. 1947
  79. Saariaho1952–⁠2023
  80. Adèsb. 1971

Full timeline, with historical events and works of art

Origins

Before Bach

Guido of Arezzo took a book of chants to Rome and taught a pope to sing a tune he had never heard. Six centuries later, Monteverdi gave Orpheus a song to charm the keeper of the underworld. In the centuries between, musicians learned to write rhythm down, to set a second voice against a melody and to write a bass line that left room for a player’s invention.

From the monochord to figured bass
Technique

The Workshop

In a Bach fugue a second voice enters while the first continues. In Ravel’s Boléro the same tune changes in character when the clarinet takes it over from the flute. Eighteen lessons examine details of this kind, using passages from real scores and short, playable examples.

Lessons from species counterpoint to spectralism